It seems like any article I read about Stephin Merritt inevitably calls 69 Love Songs his greatest triumph. As much as I enjoyed those albums, it is all his earlier works which remain my favorites. Maybe the songwriting did get better with 69 Love Songs—I’m not a good enough musician to judge—but my appreciation of the lyrics decreased. Following are my ten favorite lines from Magnetic Fields songs. Notice the marked bias towards his early work.
#1
Every time you feel wonderful, baby, I feel bad.
Either you don't love me or I don't love you, oh yeah.
When you remind me of all the good times I feel sad.
Either you don't love me or I don't love you, oh yeah.
(“Either You Don’t Love Me or I Don’t Love You,” House of Tomorrow)
Sometime in your 20s you were in this relationship. There were no glaring problems. He was acting OK, you were acting OK. But when you got near the end there was something wrong that you just couldn’t put your finger on. Neither of you were really happy, and you couldn’t quite figure out how to end it. Solution: rather than bite the bullet and break up, you decide to rummage around for obsolete radio equipment.
#2
When we kiss it feels
Like a flying saucer landing.
(“Strange Powers,” Holiday)
For most of us, I feel like metaphors and similes are best avoided. But they can be brilliant in the hands of a master.
#3
I saw you today
At the café blasé
And thought of the nights
When we had firefights.
(“Living In An Abondoned Firehouse With You,” Distant Plastic Trees)
How perfect is that word, “firefights”? It isn’t clear whether we should take it as something explicitly sexual or as particularly charged banter. Either way it evokes a relationship filled with equal parts intimacy and sparring. The placement at the end of two successive couplets gives the word an extra kick that further accentuates the passion, especially played against “blasé” two lines earlier.
Butter won’t melt in her mouth,
But you will.
(“Falling In Love With The Wolfboy,” Distant Plastic Trees)
I was in this dating disaster in my 20s as well. Don’t go for the cold, aloof ones—no matter how interesting they might be. “She’s a trollop in paisley” from the same song almost made the list. We don’t use the word “trollop” nearly enough.
#5
Why are we still screeching
When we mean soft things?
We should be whispering all the time.
(“100,000 Fireflies,” Distant Plastic Trees)
Fuck all those songwriters through the ages that have brainwashed us into thinking a good relationship doesn’t involve arguing and fighting. Fuck them. Fuck them for making us think we need to achieve effortless accord. Thank you, Steven, for expressing the love that is beneath the bickering.
#6
And your eyes are
In
(“Long
But you’re not sure if he’s saying “
#7
Like a Galapagos turtle
We grow old and stay that way
Build a nest in the sand dunes
Lay our eggs and walk away.
(“Jeremy,” The Wayward Bus)
The saddest lyrics I can think of. And another great simile.
#8
I was hoarse you were mean
We designed drum machines….
They made sounds just like drums.
I was young you were dumb.
Now you’re older and I’m wiser.
We design synthesizers.
(“Falling Out Of Love With You,” Wasps Nests)
You have to be a bit of a bitch to write lyrics like this. I’m not criticizing; I can be a bitch, too.
#9
But when the city’s so hot
The winos burst into flames.
(“Aging Spinsters,” Wasps Nests)
Once you hear the song, you can’t walk by a homeless person in August without giggling to yourself, even if you feel slightly guilty for doing it. In the same album he also refers to pigeons as “rats with wings,” another great urban image.
#10
Highway 405 will take you
From the Boom Boom Room
To interstate 5 which goes right to
The
(“
What can I say? I’m a SoCal guy. Mark this one up to provincialism…and fond remembrances of a night at the Boom Boom Room that I won’t go into on this blog.